• Lester Shaw
  Organizing President

• William Flemer Jr.
  1924

• Charles Stryker
  1925

• Jack Gulick
  1926

• Walter H. Matthews
  1927 – 1934

• Ernest Downs
  1935

• John Greene Jr.
  1936 – 1939

• Joseph P. Catelli
  1940 – 1942

• * John Greene Jr.
  1943 – May 1945

• Joseph P. Catelli
  June 1945 – 1951

• Harold G. Davall
  1952

• Joseph V. Byrne
  1953

• Richard J. Casey
  1954 – 1957

• Donald Logan
  1958

• John P. Stout III
  1959

• Leslie J. Luck Jr.
  1960

• Armand Petrillo
  1961 – 1964

• Norman H. Luck
  1965 – 1966

• Howard Smith
  1967

• Emil Brandt
  1968

• Alan G. Haskins
  1969 – 1971

• Armand Petrillo
  1972 – 1974

• Frank Stofko Jr.
  1975 – 1976

• Earl R. Mertz Jr.
  1977 – 1980

• William O’Donnell
  1981 – 1982

• George T. Luck Jr.
  1983 – 1984

• Steven J. Luck
  1985 – 1986

• Charles Dieterich
  1987

• Jeff Hendel
  1988

• Robert A. Zupp
  1989 – 1990

• ** Charles Hoens
  1991 – 1992

• John H. Luck
  1993 – 1995

• Theodor Hanasewych
  1996

• Brother Andrew Davis
  1997 – 1999

• David W. Luck
  2000 – 2015

• Robert Weissman
  2016 – 2018

• Patti Shennard
  2019

• David Luck
  2020 – Current

Former

Chiefs

• Lester Shaw
  1924
• Thomas Stewart
  1925
• Gilbert Stout
  1926
• Harry Van Note
  1927
• John Missic
  1928
• Benjamin Lackey
  1929
• Leslie J. Luck Sr.
  1930
• Bruno Miller
  1931 May – Dec
• John Spies
  1931 Jan – Apr
• Martin Higgins
  1932
• John Haupt
  1933 Jan – Apr
• John Greene Jr.
  1933 May – 1934
• John Spies
  1935
• George V. Kaltschmid Sr.
  1936
• Leo Orsi
  1937
• James McDonald Sr.
  1938 – 1941
• Herman Krieg
  1942 – 1943
• *** David Taglioli
  1944 – 1945
• Charles G. Petrillo
  1946
• Armand Petrillo
  1947
• Robert Herrmann
  1948
• George V. Kaltschmid Jr.
  1949 – 1950
• Robert Brian
  1951 – 1952
• John Nagle
  1953
• Charles G. Petrillo
  1954 – 1957
• Harry Place
  1958
• Charles G. Petrillo
  1959
• Norman H. Luck Sr.
  1960 – 1962
• Benjamin R. Stewart
  1963 – 1965
• Raymond Slovinsky
  1966 – 1968
• George T. Luck Sr.
  1969 – 1972
• James McDonald Jr.
  1973 – 1974
• Raymond J. Slovinsky
  1975 – 1976
• Norman H. Luck Sr.
  1977 – 1978
• George T. Luck Jr.
  1979 – 1982
• John H. Luck
  1983 – 1992
• George T. Luck Jr.
  1993 – 2000
• James L. Luck
  2001
• Lloyd Mathis
  2002 – 2003
• George T. Luck III
  2004
• George T. Luck Jr.
  2005 – 2010
• Lloyd Mathis
  2011 – 2015
• George T. Luck Jr.
  2016 – Current

** As a result of “Criminal Activity Towards the Detriment of the Department” which occurred after his service, Charles Hoens is categorized as a “Former Member Not In Good Standing”

*** Due to missing records, David Taglioli’s service as Chief for 1944-1945 is unconfirmed at this time.